Tray Orders
With our Trays To Go menu, you can build your own buffet – ideal for your next social event, meeting, graduation party, conference, birthday party, office function, or special occasion.
Orders are subject to availability, so we encourage you to reach out as early as possible to secure your preferred date.
Michael’s offers a variety of catering options to suit your needs, including full-service catering and event management services.
Full Trays generally serve 25-30 people, half trays, 12-15 people depending on the quantity of other foods served.
Michael’s offers a full range of breakfast items and desserts suited to your function. Call today and speak with an event specialist!
HORS D’OEUVRE PLATTERS
Mini Meatballs
HT/25: $70
FT/50: $110
Mini Sweet Corn Risotto Cakes
HT/25: $70
FT/50: $115
Mushroom Stuffed Mushrooms
HT/25: $70
FT/50: $115
Italian Sausage
Stuffed Mushrooms
HT/25: $80
FT/50: $125
Tomato & Basil Bruschetta
HT/25: $60
FT/50: $95
Roasted Eggplant Bruschetta
HT/25: $65
FT/50: $105
Spiced Shrimp & Crab Crostini
HT/25: $100
FT/50: $155
Cold Stuffed Chicken Breast
HT/25: $75
FT/50: $120
Panko Crusted Crab Cakes
HT/25: $85
FT/50: $140
Panko Crusted Chicken
HT/25: $75
FT/50: $120
Shrimp Cocktail
Market Price
FRESH SALADS
Garden Salad
HT: $65
FT: $105
Antipasto Salad
HT: $70
FT: $115
Caesar Salad
HT: $65
FT: $105
Chicken Caesar Salad
HT: $75
FT: $120
Wildwood
HT: $75
FT: $120
Greek Salad
HT: $65
FT: $105
Potato Salad
HT: $60
FT: $95
Macaroni Salad
HT: $55
FT: $90
Creamy Coleslaw
HT: $50
FT: $70
Tortellini Antipasto Salad
HT: $70
FT: $115
DIPS & CHIPS
Artichoke & Spinach Dip
$85
Lobster & Asparagus Dip
$120
Buffalo Chicken Wing Dip
$100
Cheddar & Onion Dip
$75
Mexican Taco Dip
$65
Creamy Chipotle Salsa
$65
ROLLS
Sausage Roll
$44
Spinach Roll
$43
Broccoli Roll
$43
Antipasto Roll
$44
Pepperoni Roll
$43
Eggplant Roll
$43
Chicken & Greens Roll
$45
PIZZA & PIES (48 pieces each)
Tomato Pie
$42
Garlic Pizza
$45
Garlic Pizza w/Fresh Tomato
$47
Margherite w/Spinach, Garlic,
Tomato & Basil
$50
CRUDITES
Vegetable Tray
HT: $75
FT: $110
Cheese & Cracker Tray
HT: $85
FT: $120
Fresh Fruit Tray
HT: $85
FT: $120
PROTEINS
Lemon Pepper Oven
Roasted Chicken
HT: $80
FT: $125
Chicken Parmesan
HT: $90
FT: $145
Chicken Francaise
HT: $95
FT: $155
Chicken Marbella
HT: $100
FT: $165
Chicken Marsala
HT: $100
FT: $165
Juanita’s Southern
Fried Chicken
HT: $85
FT: $135
Charbroiled Pork
w/ Marsala Glaze
HT: $85
FT: $140
Stuffed Pork Tenderloin
HT: $105
FT: $165
Pulled Pork
HT: $90
FT: $140
Eggplant Napoleon
HT: $75
FT: $115
Slow-Roasted Top Round Beef
HT: $100
FT: $160
Charbroiled Sirloin Tips
HT: $105
FT: $170
Charbroiled Beef Tenderloin
HT: MKT $
FT: MKT $
Slow Roasted Turkey Breast
HT: $90
FT: $155
Cherry Glazed Pit Ham
HT: $90
FT: $155
Homemade Meatballs
HT/25: $85
FT/50: $130
Sausage Peppers & Onions
HT: $75
FT: $120
SIDES, ETC...
Greens Michael
HT: $75
FT: $125
Crispy Fried Potatoes
HT: $65
FT: $105
Mashed Potatoes
HT: $70
FT: $115
Scalloped Potatoes w/ Ham
HT: $75
FT: $120
Rice Pilaf
HT: $60
FT: $90
Fresh Vegetable Sauté
HT: $70
FT: $110
Confetti Sweet Corn
HT: $60
FT: $95
Smokey Baked Beans
HT: $60
FT: $95
Garlic Almond Green Beans
HT: $60
FT: $95
PASTA
Chicken Rigatoni
HT: $75
FT: $115
Vodka Rigatoni
HT: $70
FT: $110
Lobster Ravioli
HT: $100
FT: $165
Hats & Broccoli
HT: $65
FT: $105
Crispy Chicken & Pesto Alfredo
HT: $75
FT: $120
Pasta Primavera
HT: $70
FT: $115
Ravioli Florentine
HT: $90
FT: $155
Chicken Marbella
HT: $100
FT: $165
Chicken Marsala
HT: $95
FT: $155
Pollo Pomodoro
HT: $80
FT: $125
Tortellini Alfredo
HT: $70
FT: $115
Baked Ziti
HT: $65
FT: $105
Baked Ziti
HT: $85
FT: $130
Lasagna
HT: $90
FT: $145
Vegetable Lasagna
HT: $85
FT: $145
Mushroom Stew
HT: $70
FT: $115
Macaroni & Cheese
HT: $70
FT: $115
Lobster Mac & Cheese
HT: $100
FT: $170
Need Chafing Dishes?
We can supply them for you & pick them up after the event! Chafing Dishes w/ Fuel $15 each **Return Pickup Charges May Apply
Full Package: High Quality Disposables Includes: Dinner Plate, Salad Plate, Dessert Plate, Silverware, Napkins | $2.50 per guest |
With Crystal Cups | $3.25 per guest |
These Selections Are By No Means A Final List If You Crave It…We Can Make It!
Contact Michael and his talented crew for custom orders, favorite dishes or family recipes, etc…
Full Trays generally serve 28-32 people, half trays, 15-20 people depending on the quantity of other foods served
- (315) 841-3077
- 7672 US-20, Waterville, NY 13480
- Wed - Sat | 5 PM - 9 PM
Contact Us
Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet, consectatur adipiscing elit, sed do eiusmond tempor incididunt dolore magna aliqua.